OpEd: The opinions expressed in this piece are not necessarily representative of Appalachia Insider as an organization. All opinions are expressly those of the author.
Appalachia Insider · May 2, 2025
**Holding On While Moving Forward**
We’ve been through a lot here. More than we probably give ourselves credit for.
The coal left. The factories closed. Businesses we’d counted on for generations shut their doors, and the jobs dried up right along with them. Our kids grew up and moved away because there wasn’t much left to stay for. And through it all, we held on. To our families, to our faith, to the land beneath our feet. We’ve held on so tight because, truthfully, it’s about all we had left that felt certain.
And I get it. I really do. There’s something deep in us that says, “If we just keep holding on, things will come back around.” We’ve been promised so many “new beginnings”—industrial parks that sat empty, outside companies that stayed just long enough to cash their checks—that it’s no wonder we meet every new idea with crossed arms and narrowed eyes.
But here’s what keeps me up at night: what if holding on too tight means we end up losing the very thing we’re trying to save?
I don’t mean we have to let go of who we are. God knows that’s the last thing I’d ever want. Our history—the coal miners, the loggers, the farmers, the families who built these hills from nothing—that matters. It’s worth fighting for. But I also believe this: if we don’t find a way to move forward, to build something new that’s truly ours, the world will move on without us. And when that happens, we don’t just stay stuck—we fall further behind.
We don’t need another slick promise or flashy announcement about some factory “looking into” Kentucky. We’ve seen how that ends. What we need is something deeper: real stewardship. Stewardship means taking stock of what we already have—our land, our people, our skills—and making sure those resources serve us first, not outsiders looking to extract and move on.
We have assets here that most places can only dream about: coal ash rich with rare earth minerals, skilled workers who know how to build and maintain real infrastructure, and communities that know what it means to sacrifice and endure. These aren’t pipe dreams; they’re real tools. But tools are only as useful as the hands that guide them.
That’s the heart of what I mean when I talk about Stewardship Economics. It’s not about chasing every shiny new idea that gets dangled in front of us. It’s about rebuilding our economy on our own terms—investing in industries that create real, lasting value, and making sure that wealth circulates here, not siphoned off somewhere else. Whether that means developing clean energy, reshoring manufacturing, or turning these hills into a hub for new technologies, the guiding principle has to be the same:
It must serve the people who live here first.
If we don’t take that responsibility seriously—if we don’t step up and claim a seat at the table—then someone else will keep making the decisions for us. And we already know too well where that road leads.
That’s why I write. Not because I have every answer, but because I believe deep down there is a way to keep the heart of who we are while building a future that works. A way to honor what made us while creating something strong enough to last.
I don’t want to see these mountains become a memory. I want them to have a future. One we can be proud of, one that keeps our kids here—not because they have no other choice, but because they want to stay.
We’ve been strong enough to survive. Now it’s time to be bold enough to build.
~CA