OpEd: The following information does not necessarily reflect the views of Appalachia Insider as an organization.
Appalachia Insider · July 9, 2025
** Why You’ll Never Get Hired If You Ask the Right Questions
We keep calling it a broken system. But at some point, we have to stop pretending it was ever built to work in your favor.
Before you even get to speak to a human being, you have to appease an algorithm. A bot scans your resume looking for keywords and formats. Suppose you don’t guess the right ones, you never even make it to the first round. You can be qualified, experienced, and ready to work, but if your resume doesn’t satisfy the machine, you don’t exist.
And if you do make it through, you’re expected to treat the interview like a gift. Show up early. Smile. Act grateful. Speak when spoken to. You are not there to evaluate the job. You are there to audition for it, and to pretend that you need it more than it needs you.
A rejection email made the rounds recently. A candidate named Gavin applied, got an interview, and asked a few basic questions. He wanted to know about the salary, the responsibilities, and the workplace culture. In other words, he wanted to understand what he was signing up for.
That was the problem.
Here’s the exact response he got after the interview:
“For future reference, asking questions about salary, responsibilities and work culture are not things we like to discuss during the interview process.”
That is not a fake quote. That is not from a joke account. That is a real company, rejecting a real applicant, for doing the very thing people are told to do. Take the process seriously.
So what are you supposed to ask in a job interview? Whether they celebrate birthdays in the breakroom?
You are required to explain every gap in your work history. You need references. You need a cover letter that sounds like it was written by a poet and a robot at the same time. You need to convince a piece of software to let your name through the gate. And after all of that, if you finally speak to a person, you better not ask what the job pays.
That is not a process. That is a maze with a trap at the end.
They do not want awareness. They want compliance. They are not hiring based on skill. They are screening for silence. The people who ask real questions are the first ones out the door, because they are the ones most likely to ask again later.
And that is what they are trying to avoid.
What they call professionalism is just obedience with a smile. The people who move forward are not the ones who are best suited for the work. They are the ones who kept their heads down long enough to be considered safe.
If asking what a job pays gets you disqualified, then they were never offering a job. They were looking for someone too afraid to ask.
~CA